Bristol Express News (BEN)Bristol Express News (BEN)Bristol Express News (BEN)
  • Local News
    • Bedminster Down News
    • Bedminster News
    • Bishopston News
    • Brislington News
    • Bristol Council News
  • Crime News
    • Bedminster Crime News
    • Bedminster Down Crime News
    • Bishopston Crime News
    • Brislington Crime News
    • City Centre Crime News
    • Clevedon Crime News
    • Clifton Crime News
    • Cotham Crime News
    • Easton Crime News
  • Police News
    • Bedminster Down Police News
    • Bedminster Police News
    • Bishopston Police News
    • Brislington Police News
    • City Centre Police News
    • Clevedon Police News
    • Clifton Police News
    • Cotham Police News
    • Easton Police News
  • Fire News
    • Bedminster Down Fire News
    • Bedminster Fire News
    • Bishopston Fire News
    • Brislington Fire News
    • City Centre Fire News
    • Clevedon Fire News
    • Clifton Fire News
    • Cotham Fire News
    • Easton Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Avonmouth Cricket Club News
    • Bristol & West Athletic Club News
    • Bristol Aztecs News
    • Bristol Bears RFC News
    • Bristol City FC News
    • Bristol Cricket Club News
    • Bristol Flyers News
    • Bristol Hockey Club News
    • Bristol Rovers FC News
    • Bristol University Sports News
Bristol Express News (BEN)Bristol Express News (BEN)
  • Local News
    • Bedminster Down News
    • Bedminster News
    • Bishopston News
    • Brislington News
    • Bristol Council News
  • Crime News
    • Bedminster Crime News
    • Bedminster Down Crime News
    • Bishopston Crime News
    • Brislington Crime News
    • City Centre Crime News
    • Clevedon Crime News
    • Clifton Crime News
    • Cotham Crime News
    • Easton Crime News
  • Police News
    • Bedminster Down Police News
    • Bedminster Police News
    • Bishopston Police News
    • Brislington Police News
    • City Centre Police News
    • Clevedon Police News
    • Clifton Police News
    • Cotham Police News
    • Easton Police News
  • Fire News
    • Bedminster Down Fire News
    • Bedminster Fire News
    • Bishopston Fire News
    • Brislington Fire News
    • City Centre Fire News
    • Clevedon Fire News
    • Clifton Fire News
    • Cotham Fire News
    • Easton Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Avonmouth Cricket Club News
    • Bristol & West Athletic Club News
    • Bristol Aztecs News
    • Bristol Bears RFC News
    • Bristol City FC News
    • Bristol Cricket Club News
    • Bristol Flyers News
    • Bristol Hockey Club News
    • Bristol Rovers FC News
    • Bristol University Sports News
Bristol Express News (BEN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Bristol Express News (BEN) > UK News > Peter Hindmarsh Barred During Lucy Letby Trial in Manchester
UK News

Peter Hindmarsh Barred During Lucy Letby Trial in Manchester

News Desk
Last updated: November 18, 2026 1:52 pm
News Desk
3 days ago
Newsroom Staff -
@BE_newspaper
Peter Hindmarsh Barred During Lucy Letby Trial in Manchester
theguardian.com

Key Points

  • Professor Peter Hindmarsh was barred by University College London Hospitals from treating patients in March 2023 during Lucy Letby’s trial.
  • The hospital cited concerns about the safety of his advice to children and young people, including advice relating to insulin.
  • A General Medical Council tribunal did not suspend his registration but ordered direct supervision of his clinical work.
  • Letby’s defence was told about the regulatory investigation but not about the clinical ban or tribunal ruling.
  • The development could be considered by the Criminal Cases Review Commission in assessing Letby’s application.

Manchester (The Guardian) November 18, 2026 – Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a paediatric endocrinologist whose evidence was central to the prosecution case against Lucy Letby, was barred from treating patients during her trial after University College London Hospitals raised concerns about risks to children. The Guardian reported that the jury and Letby’s defence team were not told about the March 2023 decision, although the trial continued at Manchester Crown Court. Hindmarsh had told jurors that two babies had been poisoned with insulin, allegedly through intravenous fluid bags. Letby was later convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others and received 15 whole-life terms.

Contents
  • Key Points
  • Why was Professor Peter Hindmarsh barred from treating patients?
  • What did the General Medical Council tribunal decide?
  • What was the relevance to Lucy Letby’s trial?
  • What could happen to the case?
  • What is the background to the Hindmarsh disclosure?
  • How could this affect the review of Lucy Letby’s convictions?

Why was Professor Peter Hindmarsh barred from treating patients?

According to The Guardian, UCLH medical director Dr Tim Hodgson told the General Medical Council that the trust could not accept the level of risk Hindmarsh appeared to pose to children and young people, even with close supervision. The concerns followed advice he allegedly gave independently to families of three child patients, including two cases involving insulin and diabetes.

In two cases, Hindmarsh reportedly advised families to stop giving insulin at home. One child subsequently experienced diabetic ketoacidosis, a potentially fatal complication caused by severe insulin deficiency, although Hodgson said it was unclear whether the episode coincided with the alleged advice. The hospital also raised concerns that Hindmarsh focused excessively on rare explanations for low or high blood sugar and did not address more common causes appropriately.

What did the General Medical Council tribunal decide?

The General Medical Council, which was already investigating Hindmarsh’s fitness to practise, applied for his registration to be suspended. In April 2023, an independent medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend him, saying suspension would be disproportionate.

The tribunal said the cases identified by UCLH raised patient-safety concerns and required Hindmarsh to be directly supervised when treating patients. It also allowed him to continue non-clinical work, including acting as an expert witness. The order had limited practical effect because UCLH had already excluded him from clinical practice.

What was the relevance to Lucy Letby’s trial?

The Guardian reported that Letby’s defence knew Hindmarsh was under General Medical Council investigation but was not told that UCLH had barred him from treating patients or that the tribunal had imposed further restrictions. The defence might have challenged his credibility, sought disclosure to the jury or applied for his evidence to be excluded had it known the full circumstances.

Hindmarsh’s evidence concerned insulin poisoning in two babies. Prosecutor Nick Johnson KC described him as the “pre-eminent expert” on insulin. The prosecution presented immunoassay results as definitive evidence, while experts supporting Letby’s Criminal Cases Review Commission application argue that such tests can be fallible and that other medical explanations were more likely.

Letby has always denied the allegations. Her lawyer Mark McDonald has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which can refer cases back to the Court of Appeal where potential miscarriages of justice are identified. The Court of Appeal has previously rejected Letby’s applications to appeal.

What could happen to the case?

The reported non-disclosure may become relevant to the Criminal Cases Review Commission’s consideration of Letby’s application because expert witnesses must disclose disciplinary proceedings or other matters that could undermine their credibility or impartiality. The development does not itself overturn Letby’s convictions, and no court has ruled that Hindmarsh’s evidence was inadmissible.

Experts supporting Letby’s application have challenged Hindmarsh’s calculations, diagnoses and conclusion that insulin was administered through fluid bags. Other medical experts, including Canadian neonatologist Dr Shoo Lee, have also disputed aspects of the prosecution’s medical theory. The Criminal Cases Review Commission has not been reported as reaching a final decision on the application.

What is the background to the Hindmarsh disclosure?

The General Medical Council opened its investigation into Hindmarsh on November 25, 2022, the day he first gave evidence for the prosecution, according to The Guardian. Great Ormond Street Hospital and UCLH had reported multiple concerns involving his diagnoses, treatment decisions and alleged patient harm. A tribunal placed restrictions on his work in January 2023, while UCLH later excluded him from treating patients in March. Hindmarsh declined The Guardian’s questions about the concerns, the investigation and his evidence.

How could this affect the review of Lucy Letby’s convictions?

The disclosure could give Letby’s legal team an additional basis for arguing that the prosecution did not provide material capable of affecting the assessment of a key expert witness. The Criminal Cases Review Commission may examine whether the information should have been disclosed and whether it could reasonably have affected the trial’s outcome. It may also assess the reliability of Hindmarsh’s insulin-poisoning evidence alongside the wider medical evidence and later expert reports. Any decision to refer the convictions back to the Court of Appeal would require the commission to apply its statutory test; the reported UCLH action alone does not determine that outcome.

First-Time Buyer Hit With £8,000 Council Tax Demand North Somerset 2026
Home, Life & You LIVE returns for 2026 with Marie Kondo as Headline Speaker
UK Consumers Favor Nuclear Over Renewables in Energy Survey London 2026
Blind Singer Ms Sunny Sarah Pursues Music Career in Liverpool
NASFAT Plans Expansion to Cardiff and Bristol After Swansea Success 2026
News Desk
ByNews Desk
Follow:
Independent voice of Bristol, delivering timely news, local insights, politics, business, and community stories with accuracy and impact.
Previous Article 7x7’s 49-Gift Holiday Guide Launches in San Francisco 7×7’s 49-Gift Holiday Guide Launches in San Francisco
Next Article 1 Injured, 1 Arrested After Shooting in Bristol, Virginia 1 Injured, 1 Arrested After Shooting in Bristol, Virginia

All the day’s headlines and highlights from Bristol Express News, direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Bedminster Down News
  • Bedminster News
  • Bishopston News
  • Brislington News
  • Bristol Council News
  • City Centre News
  • Clevedon News
  • Clifton News

Explore News

  • Sports News
  • Crime News
  • Fire News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Police News

Discover BEN

  • About Bristol Express News (BEN)
  • Become BEN Reporter
  • Contact Us
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)

Useful Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap

Bristol Express News (BEN) is the part of Times Intelligence Media Group. Visit timesintelligence.com website to get to know the full list of our news publications

Bristol Express News (BEN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?