Key Points
- The St. Paul City Council received a closed-door briefing on Police Chief Axel Henry’s lawsuit against Mayor Kaohly Her and the city.
- Council members declined to discuss details of the private meeting.
- Her and the city deny Henry’s allegations and are seeking dismissal of the case.
- Legal experts said mediation is likely, while a trial could be at least a year away.
St. Paul (5 EYEWITNESS NEWS) November 18, 2026 – The St. Paul City Council received a private update on Police Chief Axel Henry’s sexual harassment lawsuit against Mayor Kaohly Her and the City of St. Paul during a closed-door meeting. Five of the council’s seven members told 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS they could not discuss their reactions or the substance of the briefing.
What happened during the private council briefing?
As reported by 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS, the council met to discuss ongoing litigation involving Henry, Her and the city. The meeting followed legal responses filed by Her and the city, both of which deny key allegations and ask a judge to dismiss the lawsuit.
The case began after Henry filed a complaint against Her and later sued, alleging sexual harassment, battery and retaliation. The lawsuit also alleges violations of the Minnesota Human Rights Act, the Minnesota Whistleblower Act and the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act.
What do Mayor Kaohly Her and St. Paul say?
CBS Minnesota, the Star Tribune, Minnesota Public Radio and other outlets reported that Her denied many of Henry’s allegations. Her acknowledged some conduct described in the filings, including altered images and memes, but argued that it did not meet the legal standard for sexual harassment.
The city said an outside investigation did not substantiate claims of sexual harassment, retaliation or an uncomfortable work environment. The investigation did, however, find that Her engaged in offensive and inappropriate behaviour, according to court filings reported by 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS and other media outlets.
The city has also reserved arguments concerning whether Her’s status makes the city legally responsible. Legal responses state that the city is covering Her’s legal costs while disputing aspects of its potential liability.
What do legal experts expect to happen next?
Attorney Michael Bryant told 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS that the case involves an unusual power relationship between a female mayor and a male police chief, while also illustrating that harassment claims can involve people of any gender.
Attorney Marshall Tanick said sexual harassment cases involving municipalities and elected officials commonly proceed towards mediation. He estimated that 70 to 80 per cent of such cases in Minnesota settle during that stage, while about 4 per cent reach trial.
Tanick said he did not expect separate determinations for the mayor and the city, because the mayor’s role connects her actions to the city. Judge Leonardo Castro is overseeing the case, and no trial date has been set.
What is the background to the lawsuit?
Henry filed his lawsuit in September after an investigation into a complaint he made against Her. A summary released by Her’s office said the allegations of sexual harassment and retaliation were unsubstantiated, while finding that Her had engaged in offensive and inappropriate behaviour.
The city’s legal response denied that the alleged conduct was sufficiently severe or pervasive to constitute sexual harassment. Henry’s lawsuit alleges that the city retaliated after he reported the conduct.
The City Council’s closed meeting came after the city and Her filed formal responses in Ramsey County court. The litigation remains active, and the parties have not announced a settlement.
How could the case affect St. Paul’s city government?
The private briefing allows council members to receive legal information while limiting public discussion of active litigation. Any settlement, court ruling or decision to proceed to trial could affect the city’s legal costs, public administration and relationship between elected officials and senior staff.
Based on the legal experts’ comments reported by 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS, mediation could resolve the dispute before trial. If mediation fails, the case could continue for a year or longer before reaching a courtroom.
