Key Points
- Mayor Kaohly Her and the City of St. Paul denied most allegations in Police Chief Axel Henry’s lawsuit.
- Her acknowledged sharing altered memes and images but denied that her conduct amounted to sexual harassment.
- An outside investigation found inappropriate behaviour but did not substantiate sexual harassment or retaliation.
- Her and the city asked a judge to dismiss the lawsuit; no trial date has been set.
St. Paul (MPR News) November 17, 2026 — St. Paul Mayor Kaohly Her and the City of St. Paul have denied most allegations in Police Chief Axel Henry’s lawsuit, which accuses the mayor of sexual harassment, battery and retaliation. In court filings reported by MPR News journalist Tim Evans, Her admitted to altering memes and photographs involving city employees and police officers but argued that the conduct was inappropriate rather than unlawful sexual harassment. Her also denied making sexual advances towards Henry or retaliating after he rejected them.
What did Kaohly Her admit and deny?
As reported by MPR News, Her acknowledged superimposing a city employee’s face on a sexually suggestive “wienering” meme. She said the meme was part of a weekly hot-dog lunch tradition and denied writing its accompanying text, stating that the employee was not offended.
Her also admitted entering Henry’s office and posting an altered photograph showing the faces of Henry and other police leaders on the bodies of shirtless UFC fighters. She denied that the image mocked or sexualised anyone.
Her denied allegations that she made sexual advances towards Henry, called herself a “MILF”, made innuendos about the size of his uniform rank bars, called officers “beefy” or made orgasmic sounds while exercising in the police headquarters gym.
What did the outside investigation find?
The city-funded investigation, conducted by an outside law firm, found that Her engaged in offensive and inappropriate behaviour with city workers and created an uncomfortable working environment. Reports by MPR News and the Star Tribune said investigators considered allegations involving comments about a female employee’s breasts and a witness’s account that Her touched Henry’s leg during a meeting.
The investigation did not substantiate sexual harassment or retaliation. The city’s legal response said the conduct did not meet the required threshold of being severe and pervasive, while also acknowledging inappropriate photographs and behaviour involving two female employees.
Why did the dispute between Her and Henry escalate?
Her’s court response said her relationship with Henry began professionally but deteriorated over disagreements about Immigration and Customs Enforcement actions, differing views about whether residents could have “more than one truth”, and the police department’s budget, revenue, spending and priorities.
Henry’s lawsuit alleges that Her made repeated sexual advances beginning in December 2025 and retaliated after he rejected them by excluding him from personnel decisions and refusing to increase his salary. Her denied those claims, saying Henry had authority over personnel actions and had received a nine per cent pay rise in November 2025, including back pay to December 2024.
What happens next for the lawsuit?
Her and the City of St. Paul have asked the court to dismiss Henry’s claims. The lawsuit includes allegations under the Minnesota Human Rights Act, the Minnesota Whistleblower Act and the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, all of which the city denied, according to KSTP and the Star Tribune.
Judge Leonardo Castro is overseeing the case, but a trial date has not been set. The St. Paul City Council was also expected to discuss the continuing litigation in a closed-door meeting, KSTP reported.
What is the background to the allegations?
The allegations became public in July after Henry made a formal complaint concerning Her’s conduct. The dispute later led to a third-party investigation commissioned by the city. Henry filed his civil lawsuit in September, alleging sexual harassment, battery and retaliation. Her became mayor in January 2026, while the legal dispute has continued to involve the administration of the St. Paul Police Department.
How could the case affect St. Paul residents?
The case could prolong uncertainty around the leadership of St. Paul’s government and police department while the court considers the dismissal request. Continued litigation may also keep attention focused on workplace conduct, personnel decisions and the relationship between Mayor Kaohly Her and Police Chief Axel Henry. The investigation’s finding of inappropriate behaviour, alongside its rejection of the sexual-harassment allegation, leaves the legal outcome unresolved. Any effect on public confidence will depend on future court decisions and confirmed developments in the case.
